Home » Disaster Research » Factcheck: More properties inundated in 2011 floods?

Factcheck: More properties inundated in 2011 floods?

It’s been an oft repeated statement that more properties were flooded in the 2011 Brisbane floods than in 1974 despite the flood peak being a metre lower. As part of something I’m working on I decided to look further into it.

As it turns out the information available is not exactly clear. There’s a vast difference between having floodwater in your yard and having it in your house. Particularly when a source is quoted elsewhere it’s very easy for the meaning of the number to be changed. Also the source and assessment methodology is generally not listed when these numbers are quoted in reports. Here’s the numbers as best as I’ve been able to find them.

In Ipswich it looks like marginally fewer homes and businesses were flooded in 2011 than in 1974. In Brisbane though more homes were affected by flooding, it seems that fewer had water inside them.

What is indisputable is that far fewer people died in Greater Brisbane in 2011 than in 1974.

1974 2011
Ipswich
Flood Peak 20.70m 19.25m
Buildings Affected 7221
Homes Affected 3600
Homes Inundated 1800 1000
Businesses inundated included
above
600
Brisbane
Flood Peak 5.45m 4.46m
Homes affected 12700 22000
Businesses affected 7600
Homes inundated 6700 1203
Businesses inundated (partial) 1879
Businesses inundated (total) 557
Fatalities  14 1

References

If anyone can find me better sources, including those that make clear how they counted and what their definitions mean please let me know in the comments.

Report by Director of Meteorology, Brisbane Floods January 1974, Bureau of Meteorology, Canberra

Queensland Floods Commission of Inquiry Interim Report, Chapter 1, QFCOI, Brisbane

Independent Review of Brisbane City Council’s Response to the January 2011 Flood

Ipswich City Council, Community Recovery Plan

Brisbane City Council 12 Month Flood Recovery Report

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Twitter feed

%d bloggers like this: